Contributors   |   Messages   |   Polls   |   Resources   |   Register for newsletter
Comments
JohnDrake
JohnDrake
1/10/2019 2:24:52 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
which is better for
Which is better for broadband revenue for ISPs and for fiber demand for makers and installers of fiber: net neutrality or partiality?

50%
50%
mhhf1ve
mhhf1ve
1/10/2019 2:52:29 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: which is better for
Is that a rhetorical question? The incumbent ISPs are anti-net-neutrality... so...

50%
50%
Commisio44354
Commisio44354
1/22/2019 11:14:13 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: which is better for
I look forward to you expanding on it--it seems they should embrace transformation....

50%
50%
mhhf1ve
mhhf1ve
1/10/2019 2:56:45 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Op-eds trying to keep the new normal...
Elsewhere, I've seen more astroturf opinions trying to argue that the end of net neutrality has seemingly had no adverse effects on anything. The key part missing from these biased opinions is that the full effects of the end of net neutrality haven't even begun -- and some states are actively fighting to preserve net neutrality still. So network operators haven't taken advantage of all the things they might do under a net neutrality free environment.

50%
50%
freehe
freehe
1/18/2019 2:55:37 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Op-eds trying to keep the new normal...
@mhhf1ve. Good point. No one really knows what is going to happen when Net Neutrality is repealed until is it repealed. Several "experts" have only been able to give their opinion. The true effects will not be felt until the repeal is permanent. 

100%
0%
Commisio44354
Commisio44354
1/22/2019 11:13:21 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Op-eds trying to keep the new normal...
I will elect to remain optimstic because there is no other choice is there? 

50%
50%
freehe
freehe
1/18/2019 2:46:49 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Net Neutrality
Wow, this is going to be a heated case. I am anxious to see what happens. I will have to watch the news to see the case unfold. 

50%
50%
afwriter
afwriter
1/19/2019 12:12:58 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
I have a feeling that this will go on for a log time. 

50%
50%
DonBrowne
DonBrowne
1/22/2019 9:15:16 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
And this would seem to be just another example of how attorneys have a field day with hours and hours of highly paid work arguing over the finest details of court decisions, and sometimes citing dubious facts to please their clients. This will not end anytime soon I would guess.

50%
50%
mhhf1ve
mhhf1ve
1/23/2019 7:15:14 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
> "just another example of how attorneys have a field day with hours and hours of highly paid work arguing over the finest details of court decisions..."

Yup. That's part of the strategy -- to inundate consumers with arcane details that make it seem like Net Neutrality is "too complex" to figure out. And then the biggest companies with the most lawyers win.... 

50%
50%
Joe Stanganelli
Joe Stanganelli
1/24/2019 1:38:09 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
@mhh:

"And then the biggest companies with the most lawyers win.... "

This is a tired stereotype that just does not represent reality. And, speaking as a small-firm attorney with actual appellate experience, I am confident in saying that this is not the way the world always works.

I've been to court sessions where phalanxes of white-shoe law-firm lawyers were present to split their time arguing before the court. It's inevitably a cluster(very bad word), and -- even if they do wind up carrying the day based on the law -- it's in spite of, not because of, the idiotic way that work gets divided up in these situations.

And that's to say nothing of the butts I've kicked who had decades more experience and way better pedigrees than I did.

And other lawyers in firms of all sizes have similar stories to tell.

"The most lawyers" is helpful when it comes to research and discovery (because those are problems that require substantial human hours), but one driven and clever lawyer is better than 10 sleepy-eyed third-year associates burning the midnight oil.

In the high-stakes litigation context, Big Law doesn't exist to be the very very best. Big Law exists to provide credibility -- and, occasionally, scapegoating.

50%
50%
mhhf1ve
mhhf1ve
1/24/2019 1:26:13 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
@joe - Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying that when it comes to trials, that more lawyers means a court victory is assured. I misspoke a bit. By "most lawyers" -- I really meant "lawyer-lobbyists" because a large corp can essentially make the law, or at least shape policy in its favor. 

So incumbent telcos are buying politicians and sending them draft bills.. which will make it very difficult for any entities without the same resources to even have their day in court. 

50%
50%
Ariella
Ariella
2/10/2019 10:20:16 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
@mhhf1ve that's true. Even for smaller companies, just having enough resources to keep attorneys on retainer put them at an advantage.

50%
50%
mhhf1ve
mhhf1ve
2/10/2019 12:15:23 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
Also... The question of who gets to abuse consumers more: content owners vs network owners is nearly obsolete. As megacorps merge, the two entities are not distinct anymore -- and somehow the mergers have been allowed to happen despite regulations that should have prevented them....

50%
50%
Ariella
Ariella
2/10/2019 12:57:59 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
@mhhf1ve I also wonder how they get around the anti-trust laws. I'm old enough to remember the push to break apart Ma Bell after people realized, nope, there's not such thing as a "natural monopoly."

50%
50%
mhhf1ve
mhhf1ve
2/10/2019 2:50:25 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
I forget the exact details, but it seemed strange that Comcast was only required to adhere to net neutrality rules temporarily after its acquisition of NBC... that's a bizarre regulation to me.

50%
50%
Commisio44354
Commisio44354
2/14/2019 11:26:09 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
Such is not bizzare--it is frankly smart Lawyering--and it is unfortunate.   I continue to remain optimistic in spite of it all not withstanding the current chaos in Washington. 

50%
50%
Commisio44354
Commisio44354
1/22/2019 11:12:19 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Net Neutrality
Such such complex litigation are bound to take on a life of their own not withstanding the current drama in Washington--the question will be, though, who will win and who will lose? 

50%
50%
freehe
freehe
1/18/2019 2:53:04 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Mozilla
I use Mozilla. Verizon and Google sue the FCC's decision to repeal net neutrality because they are part of the capitalist system in the U.S. Greed has blinded the decision-making efforts of many executives in the telco industries. We already have too many who are underserved or unserved without access to broadband. The repeal will widen the gap and widen the economic gap. 

50%
50%
Commisio44354
Commisio44354
1/22/2019 11:07:44 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Mozilla
The continued narrowing of choice continues to be of profound concern--isn't it?  The question is as Net Neutrality withers away into the dustbin of history as we know it, choice somewhat expands or it will shrink further.

 

50%
50%
Joe Stanganelli
Joe Stanganelli
1/24/2019 1:41:53 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Mozilla
Net Neutrality is not about consumer choice; consumer rights is a red herring. It's about which megacorporations get the privilege of screwing consumers the most -- the network providers, or the content providers.

Trust me -- between costs, regulatory fees, and more, this ever-present "balance" will find its way whatever the results. :p

50%
50%
Commisio44354
Commisio44354
1/24/2019 11:36:31 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Mozilla
What is then the solution?   It seems as if whatever the majors want to do goes no matter what we little people say or think....

50%
50%
Duh!
Duh!
2/11/2019 1:53:09 PM
User Rank
Author
Re: Mozilla
@Joe Stanganelli Did you listen to the oral arguments last week and/or read the briefs? What's your take?

50%
50%


Latest Articles
Broadband-infrastructure financial firm CoBank found rural Type II diabetes patients felt better, had improved relationships with their healthcare providers -- and saved money, when they had high-speed-powered telemedicine.
As some MSOs consider the direction of their future DOCSIS investments and others embrace full-fiber, most D3.1 adopters will finalize roll-outs this year.
JP Lee, Vice President at KT's R&D Center and head of the operator's access network technology R&D group, talks about the use of AI in telecoms and how the Korean operator devised its Dr. Lauren Project.
OptiComm CTO Stephen Davies shares the Australian fiber-only wholesaler's strategy to stay ahead of bandwidth demand using 10G-PON.
Jay Shah, Chief Data & AI Officer at Singapore-based network operator MyRepublic, discusses the hype around AI and talks about what it can really do for businesses.
Broadband World Forum Perspectives
There's certainly no shortage of hype around the use of AI in the telecoms sector, but fewer instances of real-world deployments. South Korean national operator KT is one of those ...
Do a Google search of 'artificial intelligence broadband' and you'll get more than 9 million results in less than a second: The sheer volume of content out there shouldn't surprise anyone ...
Comcast, like any other major communications service provider, is undergoing significant changes in the way it grows its business, how it runs its business and the technologies it uses to ...
Five years ago, NOS board member Manuel Ramalho Eanes banked big on smart homes and smart cities.
Slovak Telekom and T-Mobile Czech Republic Chief Technology and Information Officer Branimir Maric is using his more than two decades' experience in telco, including 15 years in various ...
All Broadband World Forum Perspectives
Information Resources
All resources
Webinars
ARCHIVED
Tuesday, September 10, 2019
12:00 p.m. New York / 5:00 p.m. London

Wi-Fi is the foundation of the connected home for consumers; yet, it’s often a source of frustration. With the imminent release of the new Wi-Fi 6 standard – combined with a strong Managed Wi-Fi offer – service providers can reverse subscriber frustration while tapping into new revenue streams.

Key topics include:

  • What’s different about Wi-Fi 6 and why it matters to your subscribers
  • The importance of offering Managed Wi-Fi and its connection to Wi-Fi 6
  • How you can elevate your brand and gain a strong foothold in the home network.

Flash Poll
Partner Perspectives - from our sponsors
Radio Shows
In this insightful Light Reading radio show, Kurt Raaflaub, Head of Strategic Solutions Marketing, will outline the key service provider challenges, deployment considerations, next-gen Gigabit technologies, and service models to win market share in the rapidly growing MDU market.
Sponsored Video
Ronan Kelly, ADTRAN CTO, EMEA & APC, shares his thoughts on industry operators leveraging virtualization, disaggregation and open SDN control, ...
Network slicing promises to be a panacea, but the biggest hurdles are not technological. The grand ambition of enabling intelligent, adaptive, ...
F-Secure has been providing security for endpoints for 30 years, and using AI and machine learning algorithms, for example in the labs to automate ...
Fahri Diner, CEO and Co-founder of Plume, unveiled a new open source initiative, OpenSync, at Broadband World Forum 2018. Announced together with ...
Talking to Light Reading's Iain Morris, Sebastian Richter from devolo explains why operators have to think beyond delivering high bandwidth and ...
All Videos
Video
Alternative UK fixed-broadband network operator Community Fibre is deploying ADTRAN gear to take 10 Gbit/s to London users at aggressive prices.
At Broadband World Forum 2018 there's a lot of chat about the shift towards software-defined access networks, but how tough and how expensive ...
What are the hot talking points in the fixed broadband sector right now? Gigabit over copper as well as fiber, software-defined access and more, ...
Light Reading's pro-European, Berlin-lovin' editors Ray Le Maistre and Iain Morris discuss some of the hot topics from BBWF 2017, including Gfast ...
The UBB2020 community has had a great first four months thanks to a market that's on the up!
All Videos
Broadband World News
About Us     Advertise With Us     Contact Us     Help     Register     Twitter     Facebook     RSS
Copyright © 2019 Light Reading, part of Informa Tech,
a division of Informa PLC. Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Terms of Use
in partnership with