Contributors   |   Messages   |   Polls   |   Resources   |   Register for newsletter
Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
batye
batye
7/1/2019 7:03:58 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Optics -- is there a Moore's law?
@Ariella yes as many factors in play - some ould be accounted and addressed and some is unforseen...

50%
50%
Ariella
Ariella
6/17/2019 11:02:20 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Optics -- is there a Moore's law?
@DonBrown true, there are a number of variable that would need to be accounted for in any prediction, and it's impossible to know for sure how they will go.

50%
50%
DonBrowne
DonBrowne
6/13/2019 10:23:59 AM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Optics -- is there a Moore's law?
Without a working crystal ball, I would not venture to guess how accurate the prediction of tunable optics being too high priced will pan out in a few years. It will depend on supply and demand how just how popular might be a switch to NG-PON2 by industry leaders.

50%
50%
Alison’s Wonderland
Alison’s Wonderland
6/11/2019 9:39:34 AM
User Rank
Author
Re: Optics -- is there a Moore's law?
Good point, and one to which I do not have an answer! I think some of it comes down to scale -- what does not make financial sense for a multi-billion-dollar vendor like a Nokia, an Apple, a Samsung (not in this space necessarily with the latter two companies, but in general) can make fiscal sense for a smaller, more specialized or niche vendor like an ADTRAN, a Calix, a Comtech -- again, not in this market but looking for vendors in the sub-$700M sales space, 2018). It's worthwhile for these smaller vendors to earn x% from a costlier tech, perhaps, and earn mindshare and a seat at the table with a tier one like Verizon -- plus space at other operators that are at least piloting NG-PON2.

If you search BBWN with "NG-PON2" you'll see we've covered quite a few pilots, from Altice to NBN. Although followup info is difficult to get -- and believe me, I've tried often! -- there is interest. It's just, as all agree, a question of that cost/volume ratio getting right.

50%
50%
ngeary
ngeary
6/11/2019 4:13:17 AM
User Rank
Narrowbander
Optics -- is there a Moore's law?
Hi, great article.  I suppose the economics of the tech industry have inbuilt assumptions that ultimately stem from Moore's law on semiconductors.   I'm not aware that this can really apply to optics / optical components..... beyond simple "volume" driven -- wondering if anyone has studied this.

50%
50%
mhhf1ve
mhhf1ve
6/6/2019 2:53:53 PM
User Rank
Gigamaster
Re: Chicken and egg
Verizon seems to like to choose the technologically superior but less popular options... I suppose we'll see how end users respond. If the differential in performance isn't very tangible....

50%
50%
Duh!
Duh!
6/6/2019 2:45:19 PM
User Rank
Author
Chicken and egg
What I heard at FiberConnect reinforced the case that the future of NG-PON2 depends on whether there is enough critical mass of operators willing to buy in to push tunable ONTs down the cost curve.

At this point, VZ has NG-PON2 deployed in all of their announced 30 cities. Last I heard, CityFiber is going to start their NG-PON2 rollout in the next few months.  And that's it for actual deployments. Calix is the only equipment vendor that's producing revenue with NG-PON2.

With XGS-PON and 10GEPON riding the cost curve, the case for NG-PON2 rests on ancillary benefits of wavelength mobility  to planning, operations, SLAs etc. Despite the evangelism of The Broadband Forum and Verizon, the market does not yet understand those benefits.

 

-- Dan Grossman

 

100%
0%


Latest Articles
Excluding DT and Telmex, which were on a purchasing hiatus in Q3, ADTRAN business grew 20% over the prior quarter and generated an estimated $114 million.
'Millimeter wave is key to 5G, a path to extending the reach of wireless broadband service – and opening new opportunities for operators around the globe,' says Anders Storm, CEO at Sivers IMA.
The US Department of Agriculture is investing to provide or improve rural broadband in 14 states, across 20 projects.
Volta Networks' cloud-native virtual routing software now runs on Edgeware Networks' AS7316-26XB cell site gateway switch, the first step in a partnership the two vendors hope will accelerate CSP adoption of white box technologies across providers' networks.
As more streaming video providers enter the market and consumers find it harder to locate content, they're returning to piracy.
Broadband World Forum Perspectives
As the Senior Digital Experience Strategist at Canadian operator Rogers Communications, Lindsey Omelon build on her years of marketing experience to approach her strategy with a hybrid ...
There's certainly no shortage of hype around the use of AI in the telecoms sector, but fewer instances of real-world deployments. South Korean national operator KT is one of those ...
Do a Google search of 'artificial intelligence broadband' and you'll get more than 9 million results in less than a second: The sheer volume of content out there shouldn't surprise anyone ...
Comcast, like any other major communications service provider, is undergoing significant changes in the way it grows its business, how it runs its business and the technologies it uses to ...
Five years ago, NOS board member Manuel Ramalho Eanes banked big on smart homes and smart cities.
All Broadband World Forum Perspectives
Information Resources
All resources
Webinars
Thursday, October 17, 2019
12 p.m. New York/ 5:00 p.m. London

The ongoing debate around GPON vs EPON can get as heated as discussions around politics and religion, but both technologies offer some advantages over the other depending on the needs your network is servicing.

In this webinar, we will focus on the facts around the GPON vs EPON debate and how that technological decision is almost always made based on factors outside the technology itself.

Key topics include:

  • GPON vs EPON Technologies Overview
  • GPON vs EPON Rates & Reach
  • ITU vs IEEE – Where’s the difference?
  • Future Growth

Flash Poll
Radio Shows
In this insightful Light Reading radio show, Kurt Raaflaub, Head of Strategic Solutions Marketing, will outline the key service provider challenges, deployment considerations, next-gen Gigabit technologies, and service models to win market share in the rapidly growing MDU market.
Sponsored Video
Ronan Kelly, ADTRAN CTO, EMEA & APC, shares his thoughts on industry operators leveraging virtualization, disaggregation and open SDN control, ...
Network slicing promises to be a panacea, but the biggest hurdles are not technological. The grand ambition of enabling intelligent, adaptive, ...
F-Secure has been providing security for endpoints for 30 years, and using AI and machine learning algorithms, for example in the labs to automate ...
Fahri Diner, CEO and Co-founder of Plume, unveiled a new open source initiative, OpenSync, at Broadband World Forum 2018. Announced together with ...
Talking to Light Reading's Iain Morris, Sebastian Richter from devolo explains why operators have to think beyond delivering high bandwidth and ...
All Videos
Video
Alternative UK fixed-broadband network operator Community Fibre is deploying ADTRAN gear to take 10 Gbit/s to London users at aggressive prices.
At Broadband World Forum 2018 there's a lot of chat about the shift towards software-defined access networks, but how tough and how expensive ...
What are the hot talking points in the fixed broadband sector right now? Gigabit over copper as well as fiber, software-defined access and more, ...
Light Reading's pro-European, Berlin-lovin' editors Ray Le Maistre and Iain Morris discuss some of the hot topics from BBWF 2017, including Gfast ...
The UBB2020 community has had a great first four months thanks to a market that's on the up!
All Videos
Broadband World News
About Us     Advertise With Us     Contact Us     Help     Register     Twitter     Facebook     RSS
Copyright © 2019 Light Reading, part of Informa Tech,
a division of Informa PLC. Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Terms of Use
in partnership with