Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
Alisonís Wonderland
Alisonís Wonderland
11/26/2019 4:48:27 PM
User Rank
Author
Re: Why now?
Why now you ask, Dan? Well, don't count EPON out is what I've been hearing -- and what I've written about in an article that will appear in the next day or two. In fact, I'm tweaking it right now, with plans to post it tomorrow (Wed., Nov. 27) on BBWN. Look forward to hopefully seeing your feedback on that piece. Either way, have a wonderful Thanksgiving and thanks for responding to the most recent #BBWNFlashpoll! - Alison

50%
50%
Duh!
Duh!
11/22/2019 12:21:51 PM
User Rank
Author
Why now?
This was a current discussion maybe about 10 years ago. The differences between IEEE 802.3 and FSAN that were never resolved got down to cost **at the time the standard was being developed** versus channel efficiency and network design constraints, along with some side issues like a mandate to re-use the Ethernet MAC, telco-style OAM or not, and tight or loose synchronization. IEEE 802.3 went with looser requirements, FSAN with stricter ones. 

What's happened is that the cost advantage that EPON once had have gone away, while GPON is still more efficient and more functional. EPON's cost advantage had a lot to do with cheaper ONU optics (but with shorter reach and smaller splits). Now it's the same optics, so cost is at parity. Shipping volume favors GPON, so I understand that GPON ONTs are priced **lower** thant GEPON ones.

IEEE 802 finished the 10G EPON standard before FSAN finished NG-PON1. In addition, 10G EPON supported symmetrical 10 Gbit/s upstream at the outset, where as NG-PON1 is 10/2.5. The reason for that is too long to explain in detail, but the result is that the 10G EPON upstream is **much** less efficient than the GPON upstreams. And again, they use the same optics.

So the GPON family is more functional and more efficient than the EPON family, while not at higher cost. There is no economic or functional reason for an operator to choose EPON.

Some of the MSOs, constituting around 2/3 of the market, decided earlier on EPON, apparently for reasons other than function or economics. They also funded CableLabs to develop a DOCSIS provisioning over EPON (DPOE) specification, which simplifies operations in a mixed HFC/FTTP system. As far as I know, that's the only real case for an EPON roadmap.  A DPOG spec was started but never finished due to lack of MSO interest.

I understand that a lot of MSOs that have deployed GEPON are now deploying XGS-PON for 10G applications.

-- Dan Grossman

 

 

50%
50%


Latest Articles
A budget of $61 billion to $118 billion would enable the US to bring 1-Gig to all locations that get less than 100/20 Mbit/s service that aren't tied to RDOF phase I, ACA Connects/Cartesian study finds.
Satellite-powered broadband service provider is in talks with 'several' airlines about providing connectivity for in-flight W-Fi services.
As operators mull plans for future DOCSIS 4.0 deployments, many are considering expanding the upstream to 396MHz, a move that would deliver upstream speeds of about 3 Gbit/s, CommScope exec says.
Set for launch in early 2022, ViaSat-3 will cover the Americas and represent the first in a set of new satellites that will eventually deliver global coverage.
The UK is bustling with companies eager to build the next generation of broadband networks in what looks like a potentially nasty development for BT.
Information Resources
All resources
Webinars
ARCHIVED
Thursday, December 17, 2020
12:00 p.m. New York / 5:00 p.m. London

Todayís access network architecture is under mounting pressure due to a continued surge in the number of connected devices, a proliferation of bandwidth-intensive customer applications and dramatic shifts in usage patterns related to the pandemic, such as work-from-home and e-learning.

Learn why now is the right time for cable operators to build greenfield networks or expand their existing networks with 10G PON, arming customers with high-speed symmetrical broadband. Gain a clear understanding of the drivers impacting the access network and the various approaches being considered to deliver higher speed services. Plus, find out the best practices that operators are employing as they leverage the latest in passive optical technology to future-proof their networks.

Topics to be covered include:

  • Node + 0 (Fiber Deep)
  • DOCSIS 3.1, DOCSIS 4.0 (FDX/ESD)
  • FTTP and 10G PON
  • XGS-PON, NG-PON2
  • Provisioning 10G PON within a DOCSIS B/OSS environment

Broadband World News
About Us     Advertise With Us     Contact Us     Help     Register     Twitter     Facebook     RSS
Copyright © 2021 Light Reading, part of Informa Tech,
a division of Informa PLC. Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Terms of Use
in partnership with